Journal clubs have long been used to help medical trainees evaluate research and stay current with the literature. But while participants often find them valuable, research has produced mixed results on whether they improve critical appraisal skills.
At IDWeek 2026, speakers discussed what the evidence shows about journal clubs, how online platforms can expand opportunities for collaborative learning and how educators can structure sessions to help trainees critically evaluate medical literature.
“Something that I believe strongly [is that] one of the most important tasks of modern medical training is teaching our learners how to critically appraise the medical literature. It’s just as important as learning how to use a stethoscope, learning how to interpret a chest X-Ray or an EKG,” said James B. Cutrell, MD, of the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center. “And so, I would propose to you one way to do that is through journal clubs.”
Dr. Cutrell described two main goals of journal clubs: teaching participants to critically evaluate research and helping them stay current with medical literature.
What does the research show?
Although journal clubs are widely used in medical education, studies have not consistently demonstrated improvements in participants' critical appraisal skills.
In a randomized trial published in JAMA in 1988, researchers assigned 44 internal medicine interns at Duke University to either a weekly journal club or ambulatory didactic sessions.
Participants attended an average of five sessions. Those assigned to the journal club reported improvements in critical reading habits and demonstrated gains in epidemiology and biostatistics knowledge, according to Dr. Cutrell. However, the study found no statistically significant difference between groups in formally assessed critical appraisal skills.
Online journal clubs expand opportunities for discussion
Online journal clubs offer another approach to medical education, particularly for trainees who may have limited access to subject experts or opportunities for discussion within their institutions.
Dr. Cutrell highlighted #IDJClub, an online infectious diseases journal club that brings together clinicians and trainees to discuss published research.
In a 2020 survey of 134 respondents, 95% reported gaining clinically useful knowledge through #IDJClub, while 72% said they learned more than they did in traditional in-person journal clubs.
The survey, published in Clinical Infectious Diseases in 2022, also identified barriers participants believed the online format helped address. Among respondents, 52% reported a lack of institutional subject experts and 29% described traditional journal clubs as intimidating.
Respondents included infectious diseases physicians and fellows, pharmacists, medical residents and students.
Although the findings indicate that respondents valued the online format, the survey relied on self-reported experiences rather than objective measures of learning.
Interest in online collaboration was also evident in a separate needs assessment published in Open Forum Infectious Diseases in 2022.
Saira Butt, MD, associate professor of clinical medicine at Indiana University School of Medicine, presented findings from the assessment, in which 110 infectious diseases fellows responded to questions about educational resources.
Among respondents, 88% expressed interest in an online collaborative educational resource, even though 64% reported being satisfied with the resources available through their fellowship programs.
The findings suggest that interest in online learning can coexist with satisfaction with traditional educational resources, although the assessment did not evaluate whether online collaboration improved learning outcomes.
Dr. Butt encouraged educators and trainees to use digital platforms to share educational resources and engage with colleagues.
“If you’re going to be on social media, have some clear goals, collaborate and engage. I think that’s the key — we have to amplify each other’s ID voices,” Dr. Butt said. “Use IDSA digital resources in your day-to-day learning.”
How to make journal clubs more effective
Beyond the research on educational outcomes, Dr. Cutrell offered practical recommendations for organizing journal clubs around structured critical appraisal.
He recommended that trainees select and present articles with faculty guidance, examine different study designs and use evidence-based medicine resources to evaluate research methods and limitations.
“It’s very important that you have a structured, mentored critical appraisal approach. There are many EBM resources that are out there about helping your learners take a structured approach. There are different checklists or worksheets that can be used for this,” Dr. Cutrell said. “And when you’re presenting the journal club article, you want to highlight not just the content, but also the methods and limitations of the study presented. Oftentimes, presenting a flawed or ‘bad’ study can still be a very important learning experience for the learners to walk through.”
Dr. Cutrell also emphasized the importance of preparation and active participation. He recommended distributing articles in advance, using trained facilitators to guide discussion and inviting biostatistics or content experts when appropriate.
Predictable scheduling and protected learning time can also help reduce clinical distractions, he said.
As an example, Dr. Cutrell shared a preparation timeline adapted from the UT Southwestern ID Fellows' Journal Club. The process begins with article selection approximately six weeks before the session, followed by an initial discussion with a faculty mentor three to four weeks beforehand. Articles are distributed to attendees approximately one week before the meeting.
Together, the presentations highlighted the distinction between making journal clubs accessible and engaging and demonstrating that they improve critical appraisal skills. While online formats may offer additional opportunities for participation, the evidence presented did not establish that either online or traditional journal clubs consistently improve those skills.
Dr. Cutrell disclosed prior consulting for MDC Associates and Deepull and his role as deputy editor of Open Forum Infectious Diseases.