Clinical Report: Journal clubs' impact on critical appraisal skills in ID training
Overview
Journal clubs aim to help trainees critically evaluate research and stay current with medical literature, but the evidence discussed at IDWeek 2026 did not establish that they consistently improve critical appraisal skills. Speakers reviewed a randomized trial, self-reported experiences with an online journal club and fellows’ interest in collaborative learning. They also described practical approaches to organizing sessions.
Background
Dr. James B. Cutrell emphasized critical appraisal as an important medical training skill. He identified two main journal-club goals: teaching participants to evaluate research and helping them remain current with published evidence.
Online formats can offer discussion opportunities for participants with limited access to institutional experts. However, perceived educational value and interest in online resources are distinct from objectively demonstrated improvements in learning.
Data Highlights
Randomized trial published in JAMA in 1988: Forty-four internal medicine interns were assigned to weekly journal clubs or ambulatory didactic sessions. Participants attended an average of five sessions. Formally assessed critical appraisal skills did not differ significantly between groups.
#IDJClub survey conducted in 2020: Among 134 respondents, 95% reported gaining clinically useful knowledge and 72% said they learned more than in traditional in-person journal clubs. These were self-reported experiences; findings were published in 2022.
Barriers reported by #IDJClub respondents: Fifty-two percent reported lacking institutional subject experts, and 29% described traditional journal clubs as intimidating. Respondents believed the online format helped address these barriers.
Fellows’ needs assessment published in 2022: Among 110 respondents, 88% expressed interest in an online collaborative educational resource, while 64% were satisfied with existing fellowship resources. The assessment did not evaluate whether online collaboration improved learning outcomes.
Key Findings
In the randomized trial, journal-club participants reported improved critical reading habits and demonstrated gains in epidemiology and biostatistics knowledge. These findings did not translate into a statistically significant between-group difference in formally assessed appraisal skills.
#IDJClub respondents reported educational benefits, but the survey did not objectively measure learning.
Interest in online collaboration coexisted with satisfaction with existing fellowship resources.
Dr. Cutrell recommended trainee article selection and presentation with faculty guidance, varied study designs and structured appraisal using evidence-based medicine resources.
He emphasized discussing methods and limitations alongside article content, noting that flawed studies can provide learning opportunities.
Clinical Implications
The presentations focused on educational practice rather than patient treatment. Dr. Cutrell recommended advance article distribution, trained facilitators, expert participation when appropriate, predictable scheduling and protected learning time.
A preparation timeline adapted from UT Southwestern began with article selection approximately six weeks before the session, followed by a faculty-mentor discussion three to four weeks beforehand. Articles were distributed approximately one week before the meeting.
Dr. Saira Butt encouraged clear goals, collaboration and engagement when using digital platforms, along with use of IDSA digital resources. The evidence presented supports distinguishing participation and perceived value from demonstrated improvements in critical appraisal skills.
Conclusion
Journal clubs provide opportunities for structured discussion and research appraisal, while online formats may broaden participation. The evidence discussed did not establish consistent improvements in critical appraisal skills. Speakers recommended mentored preparation, attention to methods and limitations, and active participation.
Related Resources & Content
Journal clubs’ impact on critical appraisal skills in ID training — Olivia Anderson — IDSA Reporter — November 11, 2026 — Source article.
Impact of a Medical Journal Club on House-Staff Reading Habits, Knowledge, and Critical Appraisal Skills: A Randomized Control Trial — Linzer M, Brown JT, Frazier LM, DeLong ER, Siegel WC — JAMA — November 4, 1988;260(17):2537-2541 — https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.1988.03410170085039. jamanetwork.com
Educational Impact of #IDJClub, a Twitter-Based Infectious Diseases Journal Club — Schwartz IS, McCarty T, Woc-Colburn LE, Titanji BK, Cutrell JB, Cortes-Penfield NW — Clinical Infectious Diseases — May 15, 2022;74(suppl 3):S244-S250 — https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/ciac108. oup.silverchair-cdn.com
Online Learning for Infectious Disease Fellows—A Needs Assessment — Chavez MA, Nolan NS, Gleason E, Nematollahi S, Abdoler E, Escota G — Open Forum Infectious Diseases — Published online May 23, 2022; July 2022;9(7):ofac264 — https://doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofac264.
Based on findings from:
Journal clubs' impact on critical appraisal skills in ID training
Olivia Anderson. Idsa Reporter, 2026.
https://idsareporter.com/issues/2026/november-2026/journal-clubs-impact-on-critical-appraisal-skills-in-id-training/
This content is an AI-generated, fully rewritten summary based on a published scholarly article. It does not reproduce the original text and is not a substitute for the original publication. Readers are encouraged to consult the source for full context, data, and methodology.