Clinical Care & Diagnostics Research & Innovation

Journal clubs' impact on critical appraisal skills in ID training

Share

Clinical Scorecard: Journal clubs in infectious diseases training: mixed evidence and educational approaches

At a Glance

Category

Detail

Condition

Journal clubs and critical appraisal education in infectious diseases training

Key Mechanisms

Journal clubs aim to teach critical evaluation of research and help participants stay current with medical literature. Structured, mentored appraisal and online discussion are educational approaches described in the source.

Target Population

Medical trainees and clinicians, including infectious diseases fellows and physicians, pharmacists, residents and medical students

Care Setting

Medical training programs, in-person journal clubs and online collaborative learning platforms

Key Highlights

  • The evidence presented did not establish that traditional or online journal clubs consistently improve critical appraisal skills.

  • In a 1988 randomized trial of 44 internal medicine interns, journal-club participants reported improved critical reading habits and demonstrated gains in epidemiology and biostatistics knowledge. Formally assessed appraisal skills did not differ significantly between groups.

  • In a 2020 survey of 134 #IDJClub respondents, 95% reported gaining clinically useful knowledge and 72% said they learned more than in traditional in-person journal clubs.

  • In a needs assessment published in 2022, 88% of 110 infectious diseases fellows expressed interest in an online collaborative resource, while 64% were satisfied with existing fellowship resources.

  • Dr. James B. Cutrell recommended structured, mentored appraisal, advance preparation, trained facilitation and protected learning time.

Guideline-Based Recommendations

The source reports educational research and speaker recommendations rather than a clinical guideline.

Diagnosis

  • Not applicable to patient diagnosis; the article addresses medical education.

  • The randomized trial formally assessed critical appraisal skills, while the online survey and needs assessment examined self-reported experiences, interests and satisfaction.

Management

  • Have trainees select and present articles with faculty guidance and examine different study designs.

  • Use evidence-based medicine resources, checklists or worksheets to structure appraisal.

  • Discuss methods and limitations alongside article content. Dr. Cutrell noted that flawed studies can provide learning opportunities.

  • Distribute articles in advance, use trained facilitators and invite biostatistics or content experts when appropriate.

  • Provide predictable scheduling and protected learning time to reduce clinical distractions.

Monitoring & Follow-up

  • In the UT Southwestern preparation example, article selection began approximately six weeks before the session.

  • An initial faculty-mentor discussion occurred three to four weeks beforehand, with articles distributed approximately one week before the meeting.

  • The source does not describe a standardized schedule for reassessing participants’ critical appraisal skills.

Risks

  • Reported educational value does not establish improvement in objectively assessed appraisal skills.

  • The #IDJClub survey relied on self-reported experiences rather than objective learning measures.

  • The fellows’ needs assessment did not evaluate whether online collaboration improved learning outcomes.

  • Among #IDJClub respondents, 52% reported lacking institutional subject experts and 29% described traditional journal clubs as intimidating—barriers they believed online participation helped address.

Patient & Prescribing Data

The article concerns educational participants rather than patient treatment. It provides no patient treatment or prescribing data.

The evidence includes a randomized trial involving 44 interns, a survey of 134 #IDJClub respondents and a needs assessment involving 110 infectious diseases fellows. These studies assessed different outcomes and should not be treated as interchangeable evidence of educational effectiveness.

Clinical Best Practices

  • Use structured, mentored appraisal that addresses methods and limitations.

  • Include varied study designs and faculty-guided article selection.

  • Support preparation and active participation through advance distribution, trained facilitation and protected time.

  • Dr. Saira Butt encouraged clear goals, collaboration and engagement on digital platforms and use of IDSA digital resources.

  • Distinguish accessible, engaging educational experiences from demonstrated improvements in critical appraisal skills.

Related Resources & Content

  • Journal clubs’ impact on critical appraisal skills in ID training — Olivia Anderson — IDSA Reporter — November 11, 2026 — Source article.

  • Impact of a Medical Journal Club on House-Staff Reading Habits, Knowledge, and Critical Appraisal Skills: A Randomized Control Trial — Linzer M, Brown JT, Frazier LM, DeLong ER, Siegel WC — JAMA — November 4, 1988;260(17):2537-2541 — https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.1988.03410170085039. JAMA Network

  • Educational Impact of #IDJClub, a Twitter-Based Infectious Diseases Journal Club — Schwartz IS, McCarty T, Woc-Colburn LE, Titanji BK, Cutrell JB, Cortes-Penfield NW — Clinical Infectious Diseases — May 15, 2022;74(suppl 3):S244-S250 — https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/ciac108. oup.silverchair-cdn.com

  • Online Learning for Infectious Disease Fellows—A Needs Assessment — Chavez MA, Nolan NS, Gleason E, Nematollahi S, Abdoler E, Escota G — Open Forum Infectious Diseases — Published online May 23, 2022; July 2022;9(7):ofac264 — https://doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofac264.